The Lesson of Vocabulary Movies:

Using the iMovie Video Editor

 pup

cup

hair

chair

128x96 image of pup

 
"A video clip in combination with a text definition is more effective in teaching unknown vocabulary than a picture in combination with a text definition. Participants learned and recalled more words when video clips were provided than when pictures were made available. The variety of modality cues can reinforce each other and are linked together in meaningful ways to provide an in-depth experience. Among the possible factors that may explain these results were the following: video better helps learners build a mental image, curiosity increases concentration, and video's combination of modalities (dynamic image and sound) facilitate recall. These results are viewed as a starting point for further exploration into the use of video-based technology within multimedia environments" (p.212). "Paivio's dual-coding theory is based on the assumption that memory and cognition are served by two separate systems" (p. 204), one for verbal information and one for non-verbal information.

Al-Seghayer, Khalid. (2001). The Effect of Multimedia Annotation Modes on L2Vocabulary Acquisition: A Comparative Study. Language Learning & Technology, 5(1),202-32. [ The full text of this article is available online through a search of the ERIC database, EJ621508.]

Review

This composition provides one more example of a format for a lesson plan. It is structured in the format of a six point lesson plan model.

Once you have spent any time around computers and browsing the web, you have experienced many different ideas, techniques and procedures for working with images. This lesson extends the concept of working with still images, which was studied in a prior chapter, to a new level. This lesson has the added advantage of not requiring video camcorders or connecting hardware for its completion. A Macintosh computer or a Windows computer running Window XP provides a free video editor. What if the video clip uses a still image instead of action video? This activity will empower you to create your own video so that you can do your own test of Paivio's dual-coding theory. The completed movie will be used to run a scientific experiment in your classroom that tests the value of this approach.

Competencies

  1. Objective: Teach the basics of a video editor using still images, not video clips.
    1. Teach: Image inserts; trimming (setting the length of a clip); titling; transitions; audio file inserts; live microphone inserts
    2. Rendering or exporting the movie as digital file for insertion into Powerpoint; saving the production process data (sequence file and media) for future editing.
    3. Compare two free video editors that come free with installation of the operating system: the video editor iMovie 2.0 with the video editor Windows Movie Maker 2.0.
  2. Objective: Use the movie production process and movie product to teach and reinforce terms and topics for repetitive weekly classroom activities which require greater attention and focus by students in order to do well. For very professional examples, watch Sesame Street and other children's television shows that use animated text with images to teach letters and words. Example areas include:
    1. Vocabulary
    2. Test review guidelines including terms, dates, people.
    3. Any activity which brings to mind the concerns of "boring" or "dull".
  1. Objective: Conceptualize classroom organization methods that allow students to carry out video editing while at school.
    1. Integrate the work of the language arts teacher and the music educator to integrate this activity between classrooms.
    2. Single computer in classroom: rotation list as free or assigned activity; class teams.
    3. Computer lab time.
    4. Requires Power Mac 9.2 or later or Windows XP for the free editors. Otherwise, software can be purchased for both older and newer computers to do this kind of movie making.
  2. Objective: Teach the power of a folder or account on a computer network to move large files between computers without diskettes.
    1. upload files to the paws server account.
    2. download them at home, school or elsewhere on campus.
  3. Objective: Develop a research project based on this work by using this technique with a class of students to evaluate its effectiveness. Email the results to houghton@email.wcu.edu.
 

Teacher introduction.

If using iMovie on the Macintosh platform, the rest of this page will contain the appropriate directions.

If not, see the page for Windows Movie Maker 2.0 for directions more specific to that platform.

If needing a side-by-side comparison of the video editors, see the Video Editor comparison page.

Video Editor Processing with Sample Movies
  • Add still images to a video editor. For example, add these:

  •  
    cup pup chair hair
    128x96 image of cup + 96x128 image of beagle + 128x96 image of chair + 128x96 image of hair
  • Add animated titles, animated title overlays, and transitions.
  • See these examples of the outcomes of such composition in two different forms of video compression for two different video editors:
  • Lesson with music without voice over

    Mac iMovie

    Music track courtesy of Nifflas.
     

     

     

    You seen it done in the examples above. Now do it yourself. Demonstrate the following with one or more vocabulary terms:

     General Procedures
    in a Video Editor
    Specific Procedures: 
    iMovie for Mac OS 9

    Find Images

    The basic commands can be found in the pull down menus at the top of the screen. Once the images are on the clip shelf, drag and drop the images into a sequence within the editor.

    Option 1. a. You want to Show this Movie on the Internet.

    If so, use clip art, free web sites, hand draw and scan images,  or use a camera to shoot the images yourself. Import the images into the video editor. 

    Option 1.b. No Internet Publishing

  • You do not want to show this  movie on the Internet, only using with Powerpoint or a Media Player in a classroom. 
    • This means the ability to use a wider range of images, but creates copyright issues which will require specific reference to  claiming "Fair Use" and listing in credits the sources of the images used in the composition. This means "limited use" for showing the work, which means educational use in a classroom or behind a password on the web.
    iMovie Import menu

    Sequence Images

  • 2. Insert the vocabulary term or topic term into the sequence by making a title in front of the image over a black background.
  • 3. Optional: Insert term as title over a clip of the image.
  • 4. Add a transition between the animated title and the picture.
  • 4.5. Optional: Insert 3 seconds of black after the image.
  • In iMovie, use the menu icons to select the task needed.

    Add Audio

  • Option 5.a. You want to Show this Movie on the Internet. Find and insert audio which is free of copyright issues. Here are some example options:
    • Have the class hum or sing a song they like and know well into the microphone and make that the audio track. The music teacher can help here.
    • Use a microphone to add voice-over, pronouncing the words.
    • Search the web for free music and sounds. For example, http://www.freeplaymusic.com/default.asp.
    • Use relevant search terms to find others, for example: free mp3; free music; free aiff; free wav; or other options. 
  • Option 5.b. You do not want to show this  movie on the Internet, only using with Powerpoint or a Media Player in a classroom. Use an instrumental track (without words) from a commercial CD. 
    • This allows a wider selection of music but creates copyright issues which will require specific reference to  claiming "Fair Use" and listing in credits who created the music in the composition. This means "limited use" for showing the work, which means educational use in a classroom or behind a password on the web.
    • Using just an instrumental track keeps words in a song from potentially interfering with the words being learned. Whether this interference is significant has not been researched to my knowledge. 
     

    iMovie uses the Audio icon button just for insertion of voice over or the insertion of tracks from CDs.

    Use the Import File command under File in the menu bar (see step 1) to bring in digital audio files found on the web or created with other software. iMovie requires AIFF or MP3 audio format.

    Thought question. Do unrelated words in a song in the audio track detract from learning the vocabulary words or actually help?

    Find the Export Command

    6. Export the movie, picking from  different display and file sizes (File to Export). 

    Render the Movie

    7. Select the best video compression for your intended audience or uses. The same movie could be saved in multiple ways to provide for a wide range of audience situations both on the web and displayed from another application such as Powerpoint on a classroom computer.

    Different choices work better for different needs. Use the smallest pixel size format for those with the standard 56kb modems. Use a mid-range size for home and businesses with cable and DSL broadband connections. Use the largest size settings for showing from a hard drive.

    Guided Practice

    1. Complete the process for 2 more vocabulary words for steps 1-7 above. Keep the pace of your composition moving. That is, for this lesson, do not allow moments of stillness longer than two seconds.
    2. Pause and determine whether there is a need to contact your instructor about further questions.
       
    3. If no further questions, move to the next stage, Independent Practice, and work through the process for the remaining 2 or more vocabulary words.
     

    Independent Practice

    1. Complete the movie by including a minimum of four vocabulary words. If a longer vocabulary list was chosen, then more words can be included in the movie as long as they remain just half  of the word list.
    2. Once the movie is completed, upload the movie to your web site and send email to your instructor of the movie's file name. Do NOT link it to one of your web pages unless you have avoided copyrighted images and music or have permission to use them.

    Closure

    1. Complete research on the effectiveness of this composition process. Half of the vocabulary words were in a teacher prepared movie and half not. Teach the all vocabulary words. Use the vocabulary movie to help teach half the words. Use other traditional methods to teach the rest of the words.
    2. Send another email titled vocabulary movie results. In this email, respond to these points. Describe how you used the vocabulary movie. How many times was the vocabulary movie seen? What percent of the class had the words in the movie correct and what percent had the words not in the movie correct? From your data, can any conclusion be drawn about the effectiveness of vocabulary movies?
    3. Of the movie words that were most often missed, re-examine the movie for those vocabulary words and consider whether that  clip could have been improved to the point that the word would have been better remembered.

    Optional Future Exploration

    What if the students were taught the editing process and did the vocabulary movie composition themselves as a team or class project? Would their recall of the vocabulary words be even higher than the other two methods of the experiment? What if action videoclips of the vocabulary word were used instead of still images?


    Chapter Six: Comprehensive Composition    |    Updated February 13, 2005 |  Page author: Houghton